Hi
I need a help for "FindRoot" function.(See attached file)

Also I got an error sample file(Inst_Colebrook_pipe_data.sm) which was downloaded from this forum.

Please, guide me to solve this error.

Novice

FindRoot_test_0.sm (40,44 KiB) descargado 1280 vez(es).
Archivo no encontrado.Archivo no encontrado.

Hello [userlink]Novice[/userlink]

An important thing is that Q1 must be undefined while you define the system of equations - and as for now even when you call FindRoot; there is a buil-in function Clear(...) for this.

Secondly as for now when there are numerical functions involved in the evaluation of the unknowns this plugin has issues (in this case the issue is in if(f(Q1), that can be replaced by cases(...), however the algorithm then fails to solve for the given initial guess);

FindRoot_test_0.sm (38,94 KiB) descargado 1234 vez(es).

I'm working to improve both these things.

Wrote

Please, guide me to solve this error.

You MUST draw the diagram first !
Get inspired from NDTMA Collab [Colebrook Node].

Comments:

1. The "GivenFind" solver does not necessarily solves.
I have recollection solving for 22 variables in Mathcad 11.
It was necessary to constrain some variables, and this was
possible from some existing models, in fact: just refining
within the "solvability" of the system.

2. You have 7 'Q' indexed: that's not viable.
Instead: Q1, @2, Q3, ... Q7

3. Please rework the project to ease reading/understanding.

Jean

Inst_Colebrook MOODY.sm (21,92 KiB) descargado 1281 vez(es).
Inst_Colebrook Pipe Data.sm (59,97 KiB) descargado 1292 vez(es).
Solve Given_Find [UN Frobenius C1, C2].sm (71,34 KiB) descargado 1135 vez(es).
FindRoot_test_0 Revisit.sm (41,94 KiB) descargado 1278 vez(es).
Inst_Colebrook Pipe Data [Solve Node Flow].sm (149,29 KiB) descargado 1110 vez(es).
Inst_Colebrook.sm (191,95 KiB) descargado 1302 vez(es).
Inst_Colebrook.sm (191,95 KiB) descargado 1276 vez(es).

Dear Jean,

Thank you very much for your advice and examples
It is helpful to me.

Thank you!

MS